Review
In the third lecture, we mainly focused on the psychology of human beings. We first had an overview of human activity in social network, and then talked about the information processing procedure of human. It is very interesting to me that there are such many sub-categories of memory, and I am very curious that how our brain process memory and classify it. After that, we learnt about the hierarchy of cognition. I have never considered that human’ knowledge is a higher level than information processing, and I would like to consider it more from now on.
In the fourth lecture, we talked more about the human psychology in society, especially social networks. We learnt the social cognition theory, which is about how people learn from others, and then discussed collaboration in social network. Actually, from my various observations in life, I can feel people’s behavior is like what is stated in the social cognition theory, but it was the first time I came across the theory. It brought me to a brand new world of psychology!
Today’s Topic: Self-Presentation
The theories match my observations in life. Among these, I am most interested in self-presentation.
Self-presentation is the way that an individual represent him/herself, to match the impression that he/she want to leave to others. This concept was brought out by Erving Goffman (1922-1982) in his book The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life [1]. In his opinion, life is like a stage and people are like the actors on it. People judge how the others expect according to different situations and act to build their image.
Strategies
There are mainly 5 different ways (strategies) of self-presentation. 1) Self-promotion is trying to make others think you are competent or capable, which is usually used when one is proposing a job vacancy. 2) Ingratiation is trying to make others like you, for example, always praise or flatter others. 3) Intimidation is trying to make others think you are dangerous or dignified, and obey you, for example, a boss showing anger explicitly may make his colleagues work harder. 4) Exemplification is trying to let other respect you as a model, such as doing something moral apparently. 5) Supplication is trying to get others’ sympathy, such as stating yourself as helpless and needy. Besides, there are some other ways of self-presentation. One is called self-handicapping, which is stating there is an obstacle in front of you, then, if you succeed finally, it is because you overcome it; if you failed, it is because the obstacle.

Posting encouraging status - I think it is an example of exemplification

Posting “I’m sick” - an example of supplication, which is usually seen on Facebook
If you ask, which kind do I belong to in most situations? I think I am more of the kind of Ingratiation. When discussing with others, I seldom express different opinion towards others, even though they have a totally different view from me. Although people may apply different strategies in different situations, I seldom apply other strategies. Maybe it is because I have not interacted with others completely and have not come across enough situations!
Motivation
There are different reasons for self-presentation. Firstly, people want to leave good impression to others, and build good image of themselves, this is the basic motivation. Secondly, when one possesses negative emotion, self-presentation of a positive image can help to regulate it, by encouraging positive emotion and restrain negative emotion. Thirdly, due to need for belong, people need to show the membership of the group by presenting they are similar to each other. Fourthly, due to self-esteem, being respected by others or cared by others make people feel good, and self-presentation is one of its main sources.
Effect on Social Networking
On social networking, it is more easy to use self-presentation, especially when one is going to pretend differently from how he/she behaves normally. The reason is that the ways we communicate on social network is limited due to technology so far. For example, we mainly use text and picture on Facebook, twitter etc. Although some software allow us use different ways, such as video, people online can just see a part of us, which is easier to pretend, compared to a community in everyday life.
For example, when more and more lovers “show-off” what they do together on Facebook, men who are single are feeling lonely, because they still cannot find their Ms.right. There is even a Japanese guy who invented a way to pretend to have a lover [2]. See the picture below, he takes photo by himself but makes the photo look like taken by his girlfriend! Although most of the readers think it is useless to pretend to be in love, but it proves that pretending is very easy on social network.
Self-presentation can be seen as a kind of art and it is very hard to explain it fully in such a short paragraph. If you have any doubts, questions or comments, please leave it here and I am looking forward to it! =)
Reference:
[1] Erving Goffman, The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life, Anchor Books, 1959[2] Self Portrait With an Imaginary Girlfirend


Hi there forever-alone Japanese guy, nice to see you again.
ReplyDeleteI'm not quite sure but your whole article on Self-Presentation just sound like it's all about pretending. Without a doubt, when human become socialized, they have to satisfy the society's expectance...remind me of the joke when a kid fall on the ground, he will cry if someone is watching or he will get up and go if there is none. So that's how we play the role on SNS.
Hmm.. Actually I do not totally agree that self-presentation is all about pretending. For me, there are a lot of aspects of a person, self-presentation is just showing different aspects of him. Hard to distinguish which is the "real" one, huh? =p
DeleteYeah, you may say all aspects are real, but there are always some aspect more real... so the hidden aspect, once revealed, will seems to be pretending. Also this FYI http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/11/facebook-psychology-7-reasons_n_1951856.html
DeleteOh, your reference is very inspiring. I agree that there are some aspects which seem to be "more real", so the "less real" aspects can be regarded as "pretending". But sometimes to distinguish between which are "more"/"less" real is hard.. :/
DeleteHahaha, the boy shown at last is pretty funny.
ReplyDeleteVery good analysis! It's very complicated why people present differently in social network. I think the majority of these people can't be satisfied within harsh reality, and everyone hates to be despised by others. In social network, no one knows the true situation of these people, so they could present them in any way they like, to exchange for the feeling they can experience in a real life.
But I think there is another problem, about the audiences. No matter when and where rumors spread,(fake self-presentation and illusion might be regarded as a kind of rumor) and audiences contribute a lot in the process. If all of the audiences could reach the level of epistemic cognition, and improve their discernment, things would be better.
Yes actually I had experienced this situation. When I was in year 2, a guy in my major always posted something on my wall (e.g. "Add oil" or "Please read my message in mailbox") and made everyone in my major thought that he was proposing me. Actually he was not, and just thought thats funny. Since then everytime my friends talked about my affairs, the guy's name would be mentioned and this is really annoying. This situation keep happening until that guy was in relationship with another girls this year.
DeleteThis can be regarded as an rumor and the audience just echo the view of the others. I totally agree that if they can think more, the situation will be better.
You have a good point on four points of motivation:
ReplyDelete1. to leave good impression to others
2. to restrain negative emotion
3. to show the membership of the group
4. to get respected and cared by others or cared
somehow is another way of expressing the five ways of self-presentation that's mentioned in the class:
1. Self-promotion -- your first pt
2. Ingratiation -- related to your 3rd pt
3. Intimidation -- related to 4th pt
4. Exemplification your first pt
5. Supplication -- your 4th pt
Sorry here I'm doing a "not-that-accurate" match, hope you don't mind. What I wanna say is, social network is based on real life cases and thus conventional psychology mostly apply, thought apart from some specific features that's exclusively presented in social networks.
One more thing, ur dream that everyone reaches epistemic level is more like a fantasy, but it's never stupid to put hope in something nice like that. Let's wait and see.
Thank you for matching my points of motivation and strategies. =p I'm glad that my points can roughly match those strategies. Actually I feel hard to model people's behaviour, since there are always many exceptions need to be considered.
DeleteEpistemic level... Hmm, I think in most cases people behave based on intuition, but there are still situations that people are in epistemic level.
The self-presentation is really interesting. People can show them in different ways compared to real life. I think more reason why people use self-presentation is waiting for us to find out. By the way, the last example is great.
ReplyDelete